Court Rules in Favor of FLDS

May 23, 2008

As many of you know by now, the 3rd District Texas Court of Appeals has ruled Texas Child Protective Services acted improperly in Raiding the FLDS YFZ compound and taking custody of their children.  As an enthusiastic supporter of religious freedom, I was heartened by this ruling. The idea that was stated in the original petition by child services and argued for by the state before the Court of Appeals, namely that the FLDS belief system inherently endorsed child abuse and that the  entire  community constituted a “household,” should send chills down the spine of anyone in a religious minority.

I certainly don’t endorse child abuse or underage sexual activity (particularly involving older men) whether it is called marriage or not.  However, the idea that these cases were not investigated individually and the the justification for treating the group as a corporate entity was specifically it’s system of religious belief is utterly inimical to the first amendment and is downright frightening.  These Texas  appellate judges are to be commended for introducing a measure of legal sanity into the debate.

Further, it is my personal belief that polygamy between legal adults, particularly as a purely spiritual affair in which plural wives receive no legal recognition, as is the case with the FLDS, should be regarded as protected under the first amendment as well.  The legal justification for my position is rather complicated and I don’t have time to comment on it now but perhaps I will soon.  (My work as a union president has kept me swamped through most of the spring but is finally lightening up….  In other words, the blog is not dead!)

Since this blog is devoted to Jewish Mormon dialogue, let me add that as a Jew, I have no religious issues with polygamy per se.  Perhaps I will revisit the  position of polygamy under Jewish law in a new post in the near future.



  1. Interesting parallels Mormon and Jew. No matter who you are, this case is wrong on many levels. Yes all child abuse is wrong, but what the state has done is wrong as well.


  2. Hey Moshe!

    Good to see you back!


  3. Yeah, the government handled it all wrong. Polygamy is against the laws in the US though, isn’t it? They should have known that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: